Friday, November 19, 2010

AKKA MAHADEVI: MYSTIC OR REBEL? by Maxim D'Souza

AKKA MAHADEVI: MYSTIC OR REBEL?
Maxim D'Souza, Licentiate in Philosophy, DVK
1. Introduction
2. Brief Life Sketch of Akka Mahadevi
3. Her Intense Longing for the Lord
4. Her Challenge to God
5. Concept of God according to Akka Mahadevi
6. Splendid Vision of God
7. Last Days of Her Life
8. The Concept of Thrivedhi Philosophy
9. Akka the Source of Women Emancipation
10. Akka Mahadevi: A Mystic Saint
11. Conclusion
Bibliography

1. INTRODUCTION
India has been called the land of saints and sages. Much more this remark is applicable to Karnataka, from which the different currents of philosophy have flowed and flooded the rest of India and the whole world. The great Sri Sankar of monistic fame had his principal Math of Sringeri in Karnataka and began his life’s mission there. Sri Madhvacarya, the campion of Dualisn and Devotion, was entirely the product of this holy soil. Sri Basaveswar was another saint belonging to this eminent group.  He is called “Bhakti-Bhandhari”- the treasure devotion – in Kannada. It was he who infused fresh life into veera-shaivism and made it a living faith. His inspiring personality attracted thousands of disciples who spread his new Gospel throughout the length and breadth of Karnataka. In their attempt to interpret the new message of their master to the masses, the eminent disciples of Basava, successfully utilized His Vachanas- a new form of literature in Kannada.  These Vachanas are pithy (brief) sayings, brilliant in their directness and simplicity occasionally rising to the sublime grandeur even of the Upanisadic literature. They have brought light and hope to the Kannada masses and made their lives worth – living in all possible ways. Akka Mahadevi is one of the inspired disciples of Basava’s band.

2. BRIEF LIFE SKETCH OF AKKA MAHADEVI
Akka Mahadevi was a prominent figure and Kannada poet of the Veerashaiva Bhakti movement of the 12th century Karnataka. Her Vachanas, a form of didactic poetry are considered her greatest contribution to Kannada Bhakti literature. In all she wrote about 430 Vachanas (another source says 350) which is relatively fewer than that compared to other saints of her time. The term 'Akka' (elder Sister) which is an honorific (title) given to her by great Veerashaiva saints like Basavanna, Chenna Basavanna, Kinnari Bommayya, Siddharama, and Allamaprabhu. Akka Mahadevi was born in a town called ‘Udutadi’ in the centre of Karnataka in a Veera-saiva family. Her parents were the staunch followers of Trividhi philosophy of Guru, Linga and Jangama. She had an inborn devotion for God Siva. At age 10, she was initiated as a devotee of Shiva. She worshiped Shiva, whom she called Chenna Mallikarjuna, (Lord White as jasmine).[1] Right from her childhood unlike other young girls she chose the Beautiful Lord, Pure white as the Jasmine, Chennamallikarjuna, as her playmate.
Akka-Mahadevi was very beautiful. Her marvelous charm attracted the then ruling king- Kaushika who happened to be a Jain.
Mahadevi agreed to marry Kaushika on three conditions. They are
1.      She should be allowed according to her conveniences to practice the devotion of Lord Shiva, whom she calls Cenna Mallikarjuna.
2.      She should be given freedom to listen and to meditate the life stories and teachings of ‘Siva Sharanas’ – saints of Lord shiva – and the practices of Saivism. 
3.      She should be allowed to practice the devotion of Trividhi philosophy –Guru, Linga, and Jangama.[2]
However, the male ego in Kaushika made him blind and he forced himself on her. Mahadevi outrightly renounced the marriage, with that she also renounced her parents, luxury, home and everything, considering them as impediments. She went bare to Kalyana where Allama was heading the Anubhavamantapa.[3] Thus Mahadevi by renouncing the marriage with Kaushiaka emerged as the first protagonist of woman liberation.
She discarded clothes and other worldly things as the last vestiges of a sansarin and accepted the life of sanyasin. She left for Kalayana (a town in Bidar district of present Karnataka) which was known as God’s own city. Basaveshwara who is popularly known as Basavanna (elderly brother) has already launched a great social movement of casteless and classless society. Taking entry into his ‘Anubhavamantapa’ (the spiritual assembly) was not an easy task. Only those who are spiritually enlightened are allowed to come in, that too, after passing the kind of test held by the president of Anubhava Mantapa.[4]
Her renouncement of clothes and disregard for the body, or the acceptance of the life of nunnery was not an ordinary step in 12th century. Woman was not yet considered as equivalent to man. Her individual identity was under crisis. Even the great thinker and philosopher like Allamaprabhu questioned her unusual way of life. The picture of the discussion about this between Allama and Akka in the gate of Anubhava Mantapa¨ given by Chamarasa is not only an interesting literary piece but it is a candid and bold step in the history of whole womanhood. The discussion is as follows:
Prabhu: Why have you come here in the prime of your youth? Our saints resent the sight of a young woman. If you can disclose the identity of your husband, you can join the fellowship of our saints, or else you can depart. A woman's company is like poison. Tell us, who is your husband? Mahadevi: I was engrossed in penance for many years so that Siva might become my wedded lord! My own people wedded me to Siva by smearing my body with ashes and tying the marital bracelet to my wrist.... All the world knows that the innumerable saints have been my parents. Therefore, O Prabhu, God is my lord; for me, there are no other husbands in this world.     
When Prabhu scolds her first for her nakedness Akka Mahadevi responds in this way: I have killed the cupid in myself and conquered this world. So I have no body. When I have no body, no sex where does exist the question of clothes? It is not the condition of the body that counts but, instead, a pure heart which wins the favor of God. I have covered my body with my hair so that the sight of my body may not be a cause of temptation for others.
Prabhu questions whether Akka Mahadevi can be "one with God" when she still has human form and, worse, when it is a female body. She describes the superficiality of appearance, and of the leaders' reluctance to accept her. Would the sandalwood cease its fragrance when it's cut into pieces? Would a piece of gold, even when cut and heated, lose its luster? Would the sugar cane lose its sweetness when it is squeezed within a press and then heated? Prabhu pays her his ultimate compliment: "Your body is female in appearance, but you mind is merged with God."[5]
In fact it was here onwards that she became Akka, an elderly sister. By her profound scholarship and burning fire of devotion she soon carved for herself an exalted position in the Anubhava Mantap, the unique Assembly of Saints  there. Channa-Basava, the right hand man of Basava says, “Real greatness is only to be seen in Mahadeviakka, who has lost all sense of duality and has merged herself in the infinite.”[6]

3. HER INTENSE LONGING FOR THE LORD
Even in her childhood, she used to worship Siva with great concentration. She took her early education under Shivagamacharya and started writing vachanas at the earliest age. Even at her early age of adolescences, Mahadevi’s devotion for Chenna Mallkarjuna was so deep and passionate that she did not play with the worldly toys like other children. On the other hand as she wrote in one of her Vachanas:

“I wash away like the black soil in rain
I slip and shifts like the sand,
Anguished in dream I start awake,
And burn like the fire in the forge,
Comrades have I none in my woe
O Cenna Mallikarjuna, do Thou grant me of Thy mercy
A body that is not grappled by the groping hand,
And the ecstasy that comes of union without uniting.”[7]

Akka’s whole life was a journey in search of her eternal lover, Cenna Mallikarjuna, whom she saw in her dream and followed in reality. During this course of divine frenzy the valleys and mountains were her friends, trees and animals were her companions, sun and the moon were the guiding spirits, whom she earnestly asked for the help in searching her beloved.
Mahadevi, endowed with innate love and devotion for Lord Siva, had developed for the beginning a great aversion for worldly life. In one of her Vachanas she says, “O Lord! Without realizing Thee, I am dying in the meshes of my own self-willed desires, like a silk-worm perishing in the cocoon of silk spun out by it from its own body. Purge my mind, O God! of all evil desires and show me Thy Abode.” “This evil Samsara has been troubling me day and night. What shall I do my Lord? What shall I do to get rid of this constant harassment? I cannot bear this mental torment any longer. I throw myself entirely at Thy Mercy. Slay me or save me! Let Thy will be done.”[8]
Mahadevi had become thoroughly disgusted with the worldly life, and was constantly thinking of God and God alone. She asks, “Does a peacock ever play on the barren plain? and not on the mountains? Can a swan ever think of loving a dirty streamlet by abandoning a crystal lake? Will a cuckoo ever pour forth its flood of divine rapture anywhere except in a full-blossomed mango tree? Can a bee ever visit a flower without any fragrance? Can my mind be ever attracted by anything else but Thee, my Lord?”[9] Mahadevi thus pines to have a glimpse at the lotus feet of the Lord. “Just as a caged parrot constantly remembers its brethren outside, so do I ever think of Thee. Call me ‘dear child’ and show me ‘Thy Beauty’”.  “I am pining for Thee, day and night, My Lord! The dart of Thy Love has been driven deep into my bosom and consequently I have forgotten hunger, thirst and sleep.” Maddened by such an intense Love for the Lord, she began to request everyone she met to show her the pathway to her Lord in this manner: “Bees, Cuckoos, Parrots, Moonlight! I have one request for you. Have you seen my Lord? If so will you kindly show Him to me?”[10]

4. HER CHALLENGE TO THE LORD

This extreme intensity of devotion had made her bold enough to throw such a challenge to the Lord: “Don’t harass me, my Lord, because I am helpless. But mind, I am not a woman to be easily terrified by any amount of pain Thou would inflict. I would live on dry leaves and sleep in the bed of arrows. Pure am I, my Lord! as I have consecrated my body and mind to Thee.”  Moreover, she asks: “Will the sandal give up its fragrance even though it is cut to pieces and rubbed down? Will gold ever be darkened even when it is burnt in the fire? Will the sugarcane abandon its sweetness although it is cut to pieces, made to pass through the press and boiled in the fiery furnace? Don’t reveal my past sins to me my Lord. I will never desist from seeking Thy shelter even if Thou wouldest kill me.” She says, “Thou mayest hear me or not my Lord! I cannot but sing Thy glory. Thou mayest love me or not, I cannot but worship Thee. Thou mayest grace me with Thy presence or not, I cannot but think of embracing Thee. Thou mayest look at me or not, I cannot help casting my loving glance at Thee and sing Thy praises in delight. I shall worship Thee alone my Lord; and enjoy Divine delight by Thy worship.”[11]

5. CONCEPT OF GOD ACCORDING TO AKKA MAHADEVI
She calls her Lord as Chennamallikarjuna. In the book of Mahadevi’s path, as we turn the pages, we find that the image of Chennamallikarjuna changing. With time it merges into a higher and higher concept of the Divine. Only in her earlier years do we notice reference to Siva. Throughout He has remained her Antaryamin to whom she was wedded without a doubt. She says, “Like treasure hid in the ground, like flavour in the fruit, like gold in the rock and oil in the seed, the Absolute is hidden in the heart.” Further she says, “I am involved with the one who knows no death, nor decay nor form. He has no one place, nor any boundary, no modifications nor origins. He is Unrestricted to any clan, this casteless one is whom I love. For this reason I am for this man, this Chenna Mallikarjuna.”[12]  
She says, the approach to God must be through ardent love and devotion. She instinctively felt that man can never be fully and wholly fulfilled through self-discipline and knowledge, though self-discipline is arduous and knowledge superior. A more human approach to God lies through pure love and unselfish love which withdraws most of the obstacles that the ego interposes between the divine and the devotee.
Akka was shining star in the Bhatki tradition. Her wedding to the Lord Shiva and her undivided heart of love and surrender to Him can be considered as the path of Bhakti Marga. She also considers that the path of action is very much necessary to have genuine devotion of the Lord. In this way she finds no conflict between these two paths rather it is the two sides of the same coin. Her vachans are the best expressed form of Janan Marga, where she tries to share her knowledge of the Lord. For Akka mahadevi to know the Lord and to worship him in mind and to share this knowledge with others in Vachans was a superior way of devotion. So Bhakti Jnana and Krma margas are not mutually exclusive for the Akka, but all three margas lead us to a true devotion to the Lord.

6. SPLENDID VISION OF THE LORD
Through His grace, she had soon the vision of the Lord. “I had a Vision” she breaks out in rapture, “I had a splendid vision of the Lord. He had shining golden hair, with a brilliant crown studded (filled) with jewels. A set of pearl-white teeth adorned his beautiful lips that were illumined the seven worlds. At this sight, the famine of my eyes has vanished altogether today. Now that I have seen my Lord Playing with His Primeval Shakti, by identifying Himself with her, I consider my life to have borne fruit.” This vision brought about drastic change in her entire outlook on life. “The forest appeared to her to be full of Wish-trees; all the stones assumed to form touch-stones; every place was a place of pilgrimage; the whole world became full of heavenly ambrosia and every pebble she came across was a heavenly jewel. She saw the mountain very much dear to the Lord-Channa Mallikarjuna and entered the forest of Kadali-plantain trees.”[13]
In this way she went on having one spiritual experience after another and ultimately realized her identity with the Absolute. She says “Can the ghee mixed in milk remain separate from it? Who can differentiate heat from the brilliance of Sun? O Lord of Infinite Glory! My scales fell off my eyes as I realized my identity with Thee!” Again she says, “Whom shall I worship when my body has become Thine? Whom shall I remember when my mind has merged in Thee? Losing myself entirely in Thee, I have completely forgotten Thee with Thee.”[14]

7. LAST DAYS OF HER LIFE
Tradition says she left the world in her twenties, entering mahasamadhi (final divine union) with a flash of light. Her travels come to an end when she finds the Kadali vana in the vicinity of the Shrishaila temple. In Kadali vana, Mahadevi matures in nirguna upasana, ready for the final offering. She recognizes the Absolute in all of his creation. The kalpavriksha is all trees. The Sanjeevani is all bushes. All places are teerthas. Ambrosia is contained in all waters. All animals is the covetable golden deer. Every pebble glows as the chintamani gem. Here she also recognizes the paradox of His being in her body, as her very breath becomes His Fragrance. His form becomes hers. Her life force is no different from His very own. No knowledge to acquire, as she now knows Him. Who is there to think, of whom, as individuality ceases to be?[15]
This young, defiant and vibrant saint Akka Mahadevi attains Aikyastthala, the highest of the six states of Veerashaivism in the vicinity of the temple to Chennamallikaarjuna and Bhramaraambika.

8. THE CONCEPT OF TRIVEDHI PHILOSOPHY
According to the Trivedhi Philosophy, all holiness consisted in due regard for three vital things–Guru, linga and Jangam (the guide; the image; and the fellow religionist).
Guru: (personal spiritual master), Guru is the personal spiritual guide who has the knowledge of the path and knows how to guide one on it. A guru is the first cover/guard of soul against the attractions of Maya. He is a concept of awareness. He initiates a novice in the worship of Ista Linga, because he is a model in Ista Linga worship and is Jivanmuktha. He performs three functions: He initiates a person into the faith, trains him and guides him to move towards Aikyasthala (merger with Shiva) A Guru was forbidden to eat flesh, to chew betel or to touch liquor: and he wore a "Kempa kavi vastra"
Linga: (Siva) Linga plays a very key role in the union of Jiva with Siva. Shiva should be worshipped through Ista Linga, which is a symbol of Shiva. The communion between God and a devotee is through Ista Linga. Ista Linga is a small black ball made up of certain prescribed materials kept in a silver casket put around the neck with the help of a thread called shivadara (thread of Lord Shiva). Ista Linga is Shiva Himself. It is universal form of God in a miniature and is the greatest light of the inner most heart which is brought out and shaped into a form by the guru. It is the visible symbol of the invisible energy existing in all beings.  The guru places the Ista Linga on ‘Thanu’ (body) ‘Prana’ (life) and ‘Bhava’ (feelings). The linga placed on the thanu is Ista Linga, the linga placed on Prana is Pranalinga, and the linga placed on the Bhava is called Bhavalinga. The practice of wearing Siva linga constantly on their bodies as a mark of devotion and surrender to Lord Siva.
Jangama: (an enlightened spiritual guru) Jangama is the realized soul or the perfect one who has already been through the path and knows how to lead one there.  A jangama is a liberated man and moves about from place to place to preach the Lingayat Philosophy. He is a moving spirit of the Lord and is personified in the services of the Lord. He leads a simple life, is a man of detachment and is without shelter of his own. He is inseparable from Linga. The entry into Vira Saivism begins with an initiation rite (diksha). Once on the path, eight observances (astavarana) and five rules of conduct (panchachara) are prescribed for the adherents to achieve their liberation. The five rules of conduct are:
  1. Daily worship of linga (lingachara)
  2. Performing ones vocational and familial duties (sadachara)
  3. Acknowledging Siva as the Supreme Lord and all the Jivas as equal and not different (Sivachara)
  4. Humility and respect for all creation (bhrityachara) and
  5. Serving the community with loyalty and responsibility (ganachara)
The eight observances are:
  1. Obedience to guru
  2. Worship of linga
  3. Reverence for the jangama
  4. Smearing of the sacred ashes
  5. wearing the holy beads (rudraksha)
  6. Drinking the water used in the cleaning of the linga or the feet of guru or jangama
  7. Offering food to the deity, or guru or jangama
  8. Recitation of the Siva mantra (om namah sivayah)[16]
Guru, Linga and Jangama are treated on equal footing and are rendered with equal respect and reverence. One needs to surrender to them and seek their help in intensifying ones devotion to Siva to obtain his grace and achieve the final union.
9. AKKA THE SOURCE OF WOMEN EMANCIPATION
She is a prominent figure in the field of female emancipation. Probably, she may be the first feminist in India as she has been in a constant battle against the established institutions and rituals prevalent in India, in the 12th century. During such time of strife and political uncertainty she launched a movement that made her an inspiration for woman empowerment and enlightenment. The time was marked as height of foolishness of varnashrama dharma which only supported the three upper castes of Hindu society in India and suppressed the shudras and women.  It was in the 12the century such a feminist voice, heard from a country like India, where the patriarchal system is at its best. A time when females are forbidden at the school entrance, Akka Mahadevi could take part in many gatherings of learned men at the Anubhavamandapa in Kadal Sangama, to debate philosophy.[17]
Though she lived and died young the lines she uttered and the divine life she led keep her as an inseparable part of Indian history in general and the movement of woman’s emancipation in particular. She proves that woman is not the puppet in the hands of male dominant society. On the other hand she is as free as the objects of the world around. She was never contended with the restricted role of a girl at home. Limitations placed on women in the pursuit of education and spirituality was unacceptable for her. She proved herself that a woman has every right and has all the means to pursue a life of an ascetic. Her entire woman’s life with many traumatic experiences is a testimony to the Power of Indelible Courage and Faith. Her renouncement of clothes and disregard for the body, or the acceptance of the life of nunnery was not an ordinary step in 12th century. Woman was not yet considered as equivalent to man. Her individual identity was under crisis. Even the great thinker and philosopher like Allamaprabhu questioned her unusual way of life.[18] 
Akka becomes a distinctive phenomenon in the human history not merely by her style of dressing or unusual way of arguing. Her distinct pathway through the world, which took her to the climax point of rationalism, establishes her as an ever-shining star of boldness. Her denial of the riches and comforts of the palace and the amputations of the domestic bonds reminds one of Buddha. Her ideal of social and gender equality, propagated in the 12th century had become the creed of higher education in and out of Karnataka. Along with Basaveshwara, she was also one of the socialist reformers who spoke out against the caste system. Among her 315 vachanas, considered as sacred scriptures by the Kannadigas, one proclaims this message: “Unrestricted to any clan, this caste less one is whom I love for this reason, I’m for this man.[19]
Akka Mahadevi is even remembered and revered all over Karnataka as a seer-poet and a social reformer. You can see a number of educational and charitable institutions all through the State, named after Akka.
Akka Seva Samajas, the charitable institutions in the State, pursue the same goal Akka Mhadevi has propagated – uplifting the status of the girl children. They work for the destitute girls and down trodden women in their three branches at Kumara Park, Rajaji Nagar, Rajarajeswary Nagar along with the first one established at Bangalore. The proceedings of the Samajas are inspired by the life and teachings of Akka Mahadevi who burned up as a flash of light in the caves of Sreeshailam.[20]
10. AKKA MAHADEVI - A MYSTIC SAINT
Akka Madhavi is no doubt a great Bhakti saints of the 12th century, she experienced a call within, that no other pre-occupation distract her, in her path to the Lord Shiva. Unlike other girls, the very desire for a family and married life, and other worldly pleasure and comfort she considers these nothing compared to her devotion to the Lord Shiva. Her poems or Vachnas are the spontaneous overflow of her love for the Lord. Her cloths, beauty and ornaments were the love and devotion to the Lord. This intense devotion and renunciation of worldly affairs made her a great mystic of the time.
She had an experience of the Lord in the heart, this basic experience led her to experience Lord in everything: in the beautiful nature, mountains valleys and everywhere. She finds her home in the nature and everything in it was her companion. In union with the nature and all the being she searched for the Lord and she experienced Him together with all beings. This shows that in totality she experienced and worshipped the Lord in the Universe. This is the another aspect of her mysticism.
There is a massage for all, who search the Lord with the sincere heart that God can be experience in our simple and ordinary life situations and surroundings. There is no need of going to high mountains like Himalayas to search for the Lord; he is here within us and in the nature. Akka madhavi experienced this truth from her child hood itself, and she could experience more intensively and more clearly in her later stages of life.
She expresses the unity between her and the Absolute in the following Vachana:

I do not say it is the Linga. I do not say it oneness with the Linga.
I do not say it is the Merging, I do not say it is the Parting
I do not say it has Happened. I do not say it is to Be.
I do not say it is I. I do not say it is You.[21]
The mysticism of the  Akka is in par with the existing theological understanding of the experience of the Lord. There is no conflict with the tradition and philosophical thinking of the time. Man’s search for the Lord in the cosmos with the nature and created beings is very much acceptable to the mystics of all times. The out flow of the heart’s desire and her love she expresses in her poems and Vachana is a real treasure and guide to seek the Lord, for the many generation to come. 
Akka mahadevi is somewhat negative about the concept of body. The bodily beauty was a liability for her in her short life. She calls this body as the site of dirt, lust, greed and rage. This may be because of her experience with Kaushika and in Anubhava Mantapa. According to her the body and its temptations are the primary causes which come on the way in ones union with the Lord. In this way in her thought we can see the clear cut distinction between body as something bad which belongs to the world and soul in something sacred which helps one to live a holy life.

11. CONCLUSION
Mystics have a double aspect in their life. They are often perceived as rebel in a cultural social ethos. They refuse to walk or to follow the manmade laws and tradition. They have a fine intellect and sharp perception of divine reality. They guide people in the new path towards the absolute. They are courageous, creative and enthusiastic in walking the new unknown path with full trust and confidence. This unusual way of life and their very courage novelty and creativity make them to be rejected in the society, but later they are hailed and accepted in the society.
Akka Mahadevi was one among such saints who was intoxicated by Shiva Shakti. Because of her ascetic way of life she became true Shakti and all other powers of tradition and culture she rejected. This way led to her to the spiritual heights making her a mystic. Thus we can see that akka mahadevi had two  aspects i.e. initial rejection as rebel and later acceptance as mystic saint.
Nobody knows exactly for how many years Akka Mahadevi lived. According to one popular belief she lived only twenty-five years. Within this small span of life the achievement she did, the area she had covered from Udatadi to Srisail and the great spiritual personalities she met is something amazing. No other Indian social activist achieves the parallel position with Akka in this regard. It is sure that physically she lived a very short life but spiritually she did surpass the common level. The historians are of the opinion that Akka only in a true sense represents the whole vachana movement, which is in swing till the time present.[22] 
The vachanas she wrote is a gem of divine thought. These few Vachanas of Mahadevi gives us the insights into the unique psychology of God –intoxication of this blessed saint.[23] Even linguistically they achieve an everlasting place. Each phase of her life was a step towards the emancipation of not only of womanhood but also of the mankind. She was sure footed in her radical combat with the age-old norms of the society. She lived for the life enlightened and the life divine. Akka is a guiding spirit behind all the women activists, irrespective of the age and space. One should be thankful to the womankind, which has given “the Sappho of Greece, the Theresa of Christianity, the Lalleshwari of Kashmir, the Rubia of Arabia, the ‘Andal’ of Tamilnadu, the Meera of Rajasthan.” No doubt all they are incomparable individuals in their life and achievement.

BIBLIOGRAPHY
Deshpande, M. S. “Akka Mahadevi: St. Mira of Karnataka.” Pathway to God: A Journal of Spiritual Life 10, 1 (November 1975), 21-26.
Hampana, Kamala. Akka Mahadevi. Bangalore: Sapna Book House, 2002.
http://www.ambahouse.org/akkamahadevi.html

Patil, S.H. Community Dominance and Political Modernization. Delhi: A Mittal Publication, 2002
Shastry, G.V. Akka Mahadeviya Vachanagalu. Gadag: Paru Prakashan, 1999.
Umadevi, S. Akka Mahadeviyavara Vachanagalu. Hubli: Lalit Prakashana, 2000.


[1]Shastry, Akka Mahadeviya Vachanagalu, 7.
[2]Hampana, Akka Mahadevi, 12-14.
[3]Hampana, Akka Mahadevi, 30.
[4]Shastry, Akka Mahadeviya Vachanagalu, 11. 
[5]Shastry, Akka Mahadeviya Vachanagalu, 11-12. 
[6]Deshpande, “Akka Mahadevi: St. Mira of Karnataka,” 23.
[8]Deshpande, “Akka Mahadevi: St. Mira of Karnataka,” 23. 
[9]Umadevi, Akka Mahadeviyavara Vachanagalu, 11.
[10]Umadevi, Akka Mahadeviyavara Vachanagalu, 37.
[11]Deshpande, “Akka Mahadevi: St. Mira of Karnataka,” 24. 
[12]http://www.ambahouse.org/akkamahadevi.html.
[13]Deshpande, “Akka Mahadevi: St. Mira of Karnataka,” 25. 
[14]Deshpande, “Akka Mahadevi: St. Mira of Karnataka,” 25. 
[15]http://www.ambahouse.org/akkamahadevi.html
[16]Patil, Community Dominance and Political Modernization, 26-28.
[17]Shastry, Akka Mahadeviya Vachanagalu,  9-10.
[18]http://www.scrollindia.com/women-zone/akka-mahadevi-kannada-seer-poet.
[19]Shastry, Akka Mahadeviya Vachanagalu, 56.
[20]http://www.scrollindia.com/women-zone/akka-mahadevi-kannada-seer-poet
[21]http://www.ambahouse.org/akkamahadevi.html.
[22]Umadevi, Akka Mahadeviyavara Vachanagalu, 67. 
[23]Deshpande, “Akka Mahadevi: St. Mira of Karnataka,” 26.

RESPONSE TO "MYSTICISM: PHILOSOPHICAL INVESTIGATIONS" BY PRANATI SUNA

RESPONSE 
MYSTICISM
Philosophical Investigation
Pranati Suna
First of all, I congratulate you Br. Shijin Pulimottil, for the systematic description offered through your paper mysticism – philosophical investigations.
Our quest for knowledge and attaining God’s perfection are deep and basic ones. They are the basic and major elements that exist in the very nature of human beings.  Mysticism achieves oneness with God and also helps the person for the personal encounter with God.
Br shijin began his presentation with explaining the general notions of mysticism, in which he clearly mentioned about the meaning and definition of mysticism.
You rightly observed that eastern spirituality and mysticism is intuitive and receptive whereas in the western approach is characterized by motif of service.
Your presentation highlighted the debate on the philosophical implications of mysticism. And you have made a valuable attempt to present the various classifications of mysticism, i.e., extrovertive and introvertive, theistic and nontheistic, apophatic and cataphatic, etc…
   The blending of ineffability and paradoxicality as the various attributes of mystical experiences made a colorful blend within your presentation.
     It was very sensible to note that, Br. Shijin had succeeded in presenting the philosophical relevance of mysticism. He could forward an important definition of mysticism, given by Margaret Louis that “mysticism is the recovery of immediacy”. And this notion of “immediacy” has interpreted with 3 types of metaphors.
He also mentions about the basic and fundamental difference between philosophy and mysticism in which it is importantly noted that philosophy is by reason whereas the mysticism is led by faith aspect as in theology. The explanations for the common aspect present in these philosophy and mysticism I.e., the self actualization and self realization or Brahman itself are very much commendable.
 Blending of the PowerPoint within the presentation made the paper more attractive and meaningful. The logical sequence of each point and the mode of presentation were also praiseworthy. In a nutshell within the given time limit   Br shijin has marvelously presented the topic.
Having appreciated the significant points, I would like  to request you some clarifications. As you have mentioned that Mysticism is led by faith aspects. It looks for a direct experience of God and it seeks to    reach the ultimate reality whereas Philosophy involves rationality, reflection and reason. As I was reflecting on these points, i was a bit confused about how these two great schools, that is, Mysticism and Philosophy meet! Do they have a common meeting ground? Or they are completely independent of each other, or diverging from each other? Is there any meeting point?
            It was good to see that you distinguished the Western and Eastern concept of mysticism, given as service and silence respectively. Now my question is, according to you which concept, Western or Eastern Mysticism would draw us closer to God or help us to have deeper experience?
           You have explained well about the exstrovertive experience such as experiencing God’s presence when gazing at the rain drops or any marvelous creation of God. It would be better if you would have given a little more explanation, more examples about the introvertive experience.
Once again I congratulate Br. shijin for your wonderful presentation upon the mysticism and its philosophical investigations.
Thank you so much.

Thursday, November 18, 2010

KABIRDAS: MYSTICISM BEYOND BOUNDARIES by Akhil Vazhapilly


KABIRDAS: MYSTICISM BEYOND BOUNDARIES

Akhil Vazhapilly

          This paper deals with the mystical aspect of the stream of thought of the great Indian saint, Kabirdas. Kabir’s life and thought assume added significance, clarity and distinctness when the mystical side to it is delved deeper into. In this paper I try to bring out the subtle but deep relationship between mysticism and Kabir’s thought.  

A BIOGRAPHICAL SKETCH OF KABIR

The historical figure Kabir is placed in the 15th century A.D when he was influenced immensely by both the thriving religions of Hinduism and Islam. His entire thought is tinged with ideas and practices of this environment. Not to be left behind is the Sufi style of thought which finds regular reference in his works.    
The traditional date of Kabir’s birth is A.D 1398 when he was born to a Brahmin virgin widow but brought up by a Muhammadan weaver Niru and his wife Nima. A weaver by trade he grew up under the instruction of his guru Ramananda. According to tradition, he departed this earthly life in A. D 1518 at Maghar, not far from Gorakhpur in the Basti district.
There are probably only a few Indian authors whose verses are more on the lips of the people of north India than those of Kabir. His literature includes many passages which sound simple and yet are deeply charged with metaphysical meaningfulness. For Kabir god consciousness and poetry went hand in hand. An often-quoted verse of Kabir, which shows the profundity of his version is: “The body in which Love does not dwell is a crematorium; that heart which is without love is as the blacksmith’s bellows, breathing but lifeless.”
The literature that has come down the generations to us are his collection of poems in the Bijak, containing couplets of unsurpassed beauty, the Adi Granth, the sacred book of the Sikhs, the Kabir Kasauti and the recently appeared  hundred poems of Kabir by the great Bengali poet Rabindranath Tagore
Kabir composed his verses and songs in a mixed language of his own which is now called by Hindi scholars, Sadhukkari (language of the Sadhus). There is a roughness and ruggedness about his writing which lends it a rare charm. Most of his dohas and padas end with the composer’s name woven on it. It was a kind of copyright in those days, as there were innumerable imitators and plagiarists. Kabir is one of the rare Hindu saints who speaks the language of the Quran and he quotes approvingly many of its teachings. Most of the verses of Kabir are hymns of devotion, mysticism and discipline.

THE MYSTICAL THOUGHT OF KABIR

KABIR ON HIS MYSTICAL EXPERIENCE


Kabir’s mystical experience forms the foundation of all his later thought. He mentions the Supreme guru (the Sat guru) whose ‘word’ leads him to spiritual realization. His spiritual awakening is described in two of his verses: In fact no words can encompass that which has been realized yet Kabir tries to do so using his gift of poetic skills.
‘Kabir being beaten cried much:
In pain he cries even more.
After a blow has hit the vital part.
Kabir remained dead on the spot.’
Kabir says: The blow of the spear is easy; in being applied it takes away the breath. But he who undergoes the blow of the Sabda, of that guru I am the slave.
‘The meaning seems to be that the word (Sabda) of the guru which brought to him enlightenment seemed like a heavy blow. All his former ideas were brought to the ground under which he fainted away. The old Kabir was dead and a new Kabir arose. In many verses Kabir shows a deep self abasement. They show us Kabir with a deep consciousness of sin within him, and a profound sense of his unworthiness before God: ‘How shall I cross the sea, O master? How shall I cross the sea? I am full of many sins. How shall I serve and worship thee, how meditate on thee?
Kabir convinced of spiritual realization says, “I have met God who dwells in the heart. When a stream is lost in the Ganges. It becomes the Ganges itself. Kabir is similarly lost in God by invoking Him. Having seen the eternal beauties of the inner world, the spiritual life, he was in perfect peace and joy. Nothing could add to or subtract from the spiritual joy of his God vision. He found in the life of contemplation all he needed.

KABIR’S UNDERSTANDING OF THE ABSOLUTE

          In the first place Kabir taught and emphasized the unity of god. He is One, there is no second. In heaven, the realms below, in earth and waters, One alone Rama watches over all. Says Kabir I have searched in heaven and have seen none equal to God. The one name, like the tree of life saves mankind. Then shall man know that one God is every where contained, and that there is no second. He places the Lord of the Universe in the heart of man as his higher self, where alone the soul can discover Him. The following quotations from Bijak establish Kabir’s monotheism.
“He is one; there is no second.
Ram, Khuda, Shakti, Shiva are one
By the one name I hold fast”
Secondly Kabir says that Brahma and the creature are “Ever distinct, yet ever united”; The soul’s union with him is a love union, a mutual inhabitation; this essentially dualistic relationship which mystical religion expresses as not a self -mergence which leaves no place for personality rather this eternal distinction, the mysterious union in separateness of god and the soul, is a necessary doctrine whose features were preached by Ramanuja, handed down to Ramananda and then to Kabir.
‘So from beyond the Infinite, the Infinite comes; and from the Infinite the finite extend. The creature is Brahman, and Brahma is in the creature: they are ever distinct, yet ever united. Kabir says, “O how can I say he is not like this and he is like that? If I say that he is within me the universe is ashamed: if I say that he is without me it is falsehood. He makes the inner and the outer worlds to be indivisibly one; he is neither manifest nor hidden, he is neither revealed nor unrevealed: there are no words to tell which He is. The water-filled pitcher is placed upon water; it has water within and without. It should not be given a name, lest it call forth the error of dualism.

KABIR’S MYSTICAL UTTERANCES ON THE TRANSCENDENCE OF THE ABSOLUTE


Kabir’s God if omnipresent and powerful yet is without qualities. Kabir sometimes uses negatives in describing him and he speaks of him as inaccessible. He has neither day nor night. (Bijak, 98)

Attributeless

There are generally three attributes. Sat (Being), Rajas (Becoming), Tamas (Non-Being): but Brahma is neither of the three. It is never born, nor does It grow, nor does It die. It merely is (Tat-Sat). He is without form, without quality, without decay. As snow is caused by water and again snow melts into water, so whatever was, came to itself and now nothing more can be said’ (Kabir Granthavali). In as much as It is formless It is colourless and beyond sensual perception. All categories begin with It and so It cannot be categorized. Kabir turned Ramananda’s Ram with attributes into a formless and attribute less one who is beyond description; as the Gita says, ‘where words fail and the mind cannot reach.’

Bliss

            All material pleasures are naught before that supreme joy. Kabir describes God intoxication as something which never subsides, never lessens. He says that this godly juice is rare and dear, everyone cannot drink it.  The body and the mind cannot contain themselves when they are touched by His great joy. He is immersed in all consciousness, all joys, and all sorrows; he has no beginning and no end; he holds all within His bliss.

Knowledge                                                                                                      

            He defines it as pure and abstract. The absolute is truth to be realized, unlimited, Undivided. In this form God is light. The supreme illumination of the sufis and the stage where ‘neither sun nor moon nor stars shine and nor lightning’- as described by Kathopanishad is Kabir’s godhead.

Word (sabda)

Kabir has a very fine pada (song) describing the Anant Nad. This unlimited word is constantly vibrating. The Vedas and the Puranas describe the word, the word from which everything was born. This Word makes the gods, wise men and saints, there is no end to this fathomless word.

Void or Nothingness

Kabir describes his supreme as a void or nothingness.  It is very near Shankar’s Brahma which is beyond speech. Kabir describes his God as the experience of sweetness enjoyed by a dumb person. It cannot be communicated, Many a time Kabir takes recourse to the negative terminology on the lines of the Vedantin’s ‘Not this, not that’. ‘Beyond Vedas, beyond difference, beyond sin or virtue, beyond knowledge, beyond meditation, beyond solid or void, beyond dress, beyond alms, beyond all snobbery and form. Kabir says, beyond the three worlds that essence unmatched is.’ (Kabir Granthavali 103)

THE IMMANENCE OF THE ABSOLUTE


Kabir speaks of God as an illusionist but when he recognized him the illusion vanished. God is all pervading and must not be regarded as dwelling in any confined locality. It is useless therefore to seek him specially in a temple or mosque. Everywhere he may be found whatever name is given to him. ‘God is in the world and the world is in God and he permeates everything.’ The god whom Kabir worshipped was not a mere abstraction. He used attributes to describe him. “He is the savior is merciful, joyous, bountiful, happy, perfect and may even be spoken of as father and mother, as husband, the guest, the master etc. Kabir is not merely a philosopher who stops at the logical impossibility of describing or defining the Godhead. Being a poet he sometimes personifies his God and sometimes draws parallels between God and soul and lover and beloved or beloved and lover relationships. God abides in the heaven above, in the earth beneath and in every direction.

THE IMMANENCE OF THE ABSOLUTE IN BHAKTI

Kabir is in the line of succession of those religious leaders who advocated Bhakti, or loving faith & devotion, for those who would find God. In connection with this, he speaks often of repeating the name of God, especially the name of Rama. Kabir finds love or bhakti the easiest way to realize the Infinite within one’s own self. He is positive that God can be seen only in the being of man and that then the whole universe becomes a mirror reflecting the bliss and beauty of God. However this is not merely a magic formula. The mere repetition of the name of God would not bring salvation any more, than a man can taste sweetness by repeating the word ‘sugar’. The repetition of the name of God, seems rather to be a means by which he reminds himself of God’s reality and brings to recollection all that the name connotes and so it helps him to realize his union with God.

THE NAME OF THE ABSOLUTE

Call it by any appellation it matters little. Jaydev invoked Ram and Govind. Namdev, Vitthal and the various saints have used various names. Kabir in one of his padas, enumerates all such names and comes to the conclusion. “Called by any name, You remain the same!”

Many of the most beautiful hymns of Kabir are the expressions of his heart’s devotion to the Lord immanent. The name of God dearest to Kabir is Ram. The repetition of the name of Ram, according to the saint, removes all the sins of man and makes him fit to see God in his heart.

KABIR’S UNDERSTANDING OF THE RELATION BETWEEN SELF AND THE REAL

The soul and the goal of the soul (moving towards spiritual consciousness)

            Kabir’s conception of the soul is enigmatic and full of apparent contradictions. It is the living being, the breath, the self, the ego, the sexless entity, the Atman.
The Atman is formless, boundless beyond all change. ‘It is like a drop in the ocean it cannot be separated, the ocean-ness is in the drop-ness.’ The soul is non-dual self-illuminated, ever living, and the finest of the fine. It leaves the cage called body.
He makes a distinction in the states of the soul- surati- stands for the bound or attached soul and nirati for the free or the non – attached one. Kabir discusses the causes of the error bound soul, the directionless soul, and the soul which is trying to break through.  Ultimately to be free of all attachments and to reach the higher stage, the soul has to be ego- less, without enmity, seeking enlightenment. The goal of salvation according to Kabir is re-absorption into God as the soul of the world. He does not desire heaven nor does he fear hell, but he longs for this union. Kabir again says ‘one knows oneself by oneself’. For Kabir knowledge of the self is the supreme discipline the be-all and end- all of every human life.

The concept of love, renunciation and ultimate emancipation

Kabir says “Some contemplate the formless, and others meditate on form: but the wise man knows the brahma is beyond both.
That beauty of his is not seen of the eye: that metre of his is not heard of the ear. Kabir says: ‘he who has found both love and renunciation never descends to death.” Once the devotee is engaged in helping and serving all and has achieved equanimity of vision he need not be afraid of any thing. If one has to be afraid of anything, it is of the evil within. To break away from the revolving wheel of birth copulation and death and to let the flame pass into the bigger Flame is what he calls the great meeting with the Infinite. Kabir calls the state of nirvana (the ultimate meaningful truth) a safe and fearless condition. For Kabir the bondage is only a subjective illusion. Once it is broken the non – duality is the only experience left. ‘The pitcher is in water and water is in the pitcher; once the pitcher is broken, water is mingled in water.’  If a reflection falls in two pitchers full of water floating in the water, and the pitchers break, the reflection is scattered and yet reflected in larger water- the reflection remains one.

The Transitoriness of life

          We find Kabir as a man who is face to face with the great mysteries of life, one who thinks deeply with regard to the problems of death and the life beyond. He earnestly calls all men to turn away from sin and seek God before it is too late the opportunity of life be gone. Men often bestow much thought on the body, but one day it will perish. No one can escape from death, which he personifies as Yama. But for those whose minds have been filled with divine knowledge and have realized their union God death is not to be dreaded, for it is the gate, which leads to happiness. Kabir himself there fore has no fear of death.

KABIR AS A CRITIC OF RELIGIOUS PRACTICES AND SOCIAL EVILS


Kabir had nothing but condemnation for these who performed ceremonial ablutions and cleansings and went through elaborate rituals to find God but paid no attention to the purification of the heart. What is the use of all this ceremonials and rituals when men harbour deceit within and practice fraud under the guise of holiness. These mere rituals cannot in themselves expel evil, wherever man is, his heart is full of wickedness. Kabir says” whether I be in the temple or the balcony in the camp or in the flower garden, I tell you truly that every moment my lord is taking delight in me.’
Kabir  has no regard for the Vedas the Quran or other so called sacred books. He may have respected in some ways their teaching but not the superstitious and unmeaning regard for them held by pandits, mullas and others. He disapproved of the rites of circumcision and discouraged pilgrimages to Mecca and even the slaughtering of animals. Kabir strongly condemns the rituals for the dead. He does so because while alive the old are not taken care of or shown love. Food and water are scarcely supplied but for the rituals all such things are included. After cremating the dead body at the burning ghat, they make a show of great love and attachment.
Kabir also had a very strong derision for social evils. It hurt him a lot when the people were ill-treated by their own fellow beings while the absolute made no such distinctions. Kabir disapproved of the caste system. Kabir was a bitter critic of all kinds of sectarian and narrow creeds and outlooks. He rose above the divisions that separated men and believing as he did in one God sought to make men realize they were all one family in him. Kabir respected the individual self and the dignity of women and hence he strongly condemns the practice of sati. Kabir held very strongly the doctrine of Ahimsa or the sin of taking life in any form; especially the sacrifice of the animals in worship, the non-destruction of flowers. For Kabir, moral life involves adherence to ahimsa.
He denounced a large number of practices of both Hindus and Moslems which seemed to him to be mere out ward forms and superstitions and to have no value in leading men into real fellowship with god.

CONCLUSION

          Little as we know of the circumstances of the life of Kabir, what has been presented above suffices to help us to form a picture of the mystic he really was. We see a poor unlettered weaver in a humble home, having to struggle hard to earn his daily bread, but with a deeply religious and earnest nature which longed for union with god. In his intense eagerness to find out the reality of things eternal, and his hatred of shams, he was contemptuous of all merely formal and outward piety, and regardless of conventions of caste or society. Often misunderstood by his family, and brought into violent opposition with the society around him, because of his denunciation of its sins and exposure of its follies, he takes refuge in god and finds his solace in communion with Him.
Like other great mystics he was in many things before his age, seeing things which the world around him would take centuries to learn; and yet, like other great men also, he never shook himself entirely free from his environment and the limitations which it involved.
Kabir was not merely a mystic who dwelt in his metaphysical-abode, far away from the maddenning crowd. In Kabir's wide and rapturous vision of the universe he never loses touch with the common life. His feet are firmly planted upon earth; his lofty and passionate apprehensions are perpetually controlled by the activity of a sane and vigorous intellect, by the alert commonsense so often found in persons of real mystical genius. The constant insistence on simplicity and directness, the hatred of all abstractions and philosophisings, the ruthless criticism of external religion: these are amongst his most marked characteristics which undoubtedly give him a high place amongst the great men and mystics of India.